The Name of the Rose
Second Day: After Vespers (pp. 156-59)


The previous study page was Second Day: Nones (pp. 142-54). Click here to return to study page index.
Click here to return to the
ENG 510 syllabus.
Address questions or comments to Professor Anderson.




You must not transgress the pillars of Hercules Pgs. 157-158. Marlene Walkush comments. While the short chapter titled "After Vespers" from pages 156-159 has biblical reference, it also has reference to Greek mythology, particularly the story of Hercules. Hercules, after killing his wife in a mindless rage, wanted to avenge himself of their deaths. However, Theseus, an aged hero to the Athenians, was the first to knowlingly accepted Hercules and encouraged him to "suffer and be strong." (1) The oracle at Delphi bade Hercules to submit to whatever King Eurystheus, his cousin, asked. Eurystheus devised a series of penances or twelve labors. The second one called for Hercules to kill a nine headed Hydra which lived in the sea. When Hercules cut off a head, two grew back in its place. The third labor was to bring back alive a stag with horns of gold. The fourth labor was to capture a great beastly boar. The tenth labor ws to bring back the cattle of Gergon, who was a monster with three bodies living on a Western island. On his way there, Hercules reached the land at the end of the Mediterranean and he set up as a memorial of his journey two great rocks called the pillars of Hercules. The twelfth labor, the worst of all, was to free Theseus from the lower world. Hercules' task was to bring Cerberus, the three headed dog up from Hades.

On page 157 of The Name of the Rose, William on a walk "in the cold evening air" happens upon "old Alinardo of Grottoferrata who, miraculously like a Greek god, doesn't seem to "feel the cold." He then offers a return greeting that has mythological connotations when he states that affairs are "peaceful in the heavens, but grim on earth." Then upon questioning from William, like an oracle, he offers a prophecy about the "beast" he thinks is "roaming about the abbey." He states: "The great beast that comes from the sea...Seven heads and ten horns and upon his horns ten crowns and upon his heads three names of blasphemy. The beast like unto a leopard, with the feet of a bear, and the mouth of a lion...I have seen him." Then he goes on to give William a sign to guide him. Alinardo,like Theseus is first to accept Hercules, is the first one to tell William that the "library is a labyrinth." Then, acting very much like a prophetic god, he cautions Williams about it by telling him that "You enter and you do not know whether you will come out [of the underworld]. You must not transgress the pillars of Hercules..."

The scene could easily be translated to Greek mythology especially since Eco brings in the pillars of Hercules, beasts, prophecies, and references to the underworld.
(1) Hamilton, Edith. Mythology: Timeless Tales of Gods and Heroes. (Ny,Ny: New American Library, 1940.
Donation of Constantine (p. 158): [Joe Motta comments] Alinardo believes that the coming of the Antichrist must be dated from the donation of Constantine, three centuries after the birth of Christ. The donation refers to a document, purportedly issued by Constantine near the time of his conversion, by which he invested Pope Sylvester I (314-15) with the same privileges and authority as the emperor, including the right to wear an imperial crown, a purple cloak and tunic, and all imperial insignia. The document also makes a gift to the Pope and his successors of Rome and various provinces in Italy and Western Europe. It further states that the Constantine has established a new capital in the East and is moving his government there because it is inappropriate for a secular emperor to exercise power at the seat of the Church.

In the 15th century the document was recognized as a forgery that was drafted sometime between the years 750 and 850. Many historians contend that the forgery was perpetrated at Rome and was intended to support the claims of the popes to secular power. Some assert that its primary objective was the increase of papal power over imperial authority and the establishment of the political supremacy of the pope over the whole West.

The first pope who relied on the document to justify his secular authority was Leo IX, who in a letter to the Patriarch of Constantinople dated 1054, cites the “Donatio” to establish that the Holy See possessed both earthly and heavenly imperium. Thereafter, the document acquired more importance and was cited more frequently in the ecclesiastical and political struggles between popes and secular rulers.

At the time of the events of The Name of the Rose, the donation of Constantine would not have been recognized as a forgery. As a consequence it undoubtedly played an important role in battle between Louis of Bavaria and John XXII for control of Western Europe. Louis’ support for the theologians who asserted the poverty of Christ represented an attempt to discredit the Church’s claim to secular authority based on the donation of Constantine.
The next study page is Second Day: Compline (pp. 160-68)